I think it's safe to say in hindsight that the band was held back by sexism, which was rampant in the rock world at that time. There are countless stories of them being dismissed simply because they were women. Furthermore, two of the band members, including the lead singer, were in part ethnically Filipino, so racism held them back too. But I also think it's safe to say that if you just listen to their music, Bowie was right.
If you want to know more about them, here's their Wikipedia page:
They did okay in terms of sales, having a few minor hits. Yet it's shocking to me how little known they are these days. You'd think they'd be considered trailblazers for women in rock, much like Janis Joplin, Grace Slick, and Joni Mitchell, but instead it seems they'd disappeared down the memory hole. But at least many famous all-female bands like the Runaways, the Bangles, and the Go-Go's were very aware of them and cite them as a key influence.
Anyway, getting to the music here, there is one official live album from them. But as far as I can tell, there are no other live recordings, no bootlegs, other than their appearances on some TV shows where they actually played live instead of lipsyncing. I've collected all of those here.
I think it makes for a very good album. Everything here is officially unreleased. Yet the sound quality is excellent throughout. On all but three of the songs, these were recorded in studios without an audience, so that helps the sound quality.
Eleven of the 16 songs come from two appearances on the German TV show "Beat Club." That helped ensure that they didn't play the same few songs over and over. There are a couple of instances where the same songs were played more than once, and I didn't include those. But there were literally only two or three cases of that, which is lucky.
Most of the songs are originals, except for "Hey Bulldog" by the Beatles, "Ain't That Peculiar" by Marvin Gaye, "Special Care" by Buffalo Springfield, "Badge" by Cream, and "Last Night I Had a Dream" by Randy Newman. That list alone strongly suggested they had excellent music taste.
This doesn't contain all their best songs, but it does contain most of them. Furthermore, I think they played with more fire on these live versions than on their album versions. So if you're not familiar with them, this is a good place to start. And if you do have their officially released music, I'll bet you don't have this.
This album is an hour and five minutes long.
01 Cat Fever (Fanny)
02 Charity Ball (Fanny)
03 Place in the Country (Fanny)
04 Hey Bulldog (Fanny)
05 talk (Fanny)
06 Thinking of You (Fanny)
07 talk (Fanny)
08 Ain't That Peculiar (Fanny)
09 talk (Fanny)
10 Blind Alley (Fanny)
11 talk (Fanny)
12 Special Care (Fanny)
13 You're the One (Fanny)
14 Badge (Fanny)
15 Young and Dumb (Fanny)
16 Summer Song (Fanny)
17 Knock on My Door (Fanny)
18 Borrowed Time (Fanny)
19 All Mine (Fanny)
20 Last Night I Had a Dream (Fanny)
https://www.upload.ee/files/15289915/Fany_1971-1973_LveonTV_atse.zip.html
Since most of the songs were played on "Beat Club," I figured it would be appropriate to have a cover image from that. So I took a screenshot from one of their "Beat Club" videos found on YouTube. The picture quality is rather low-res, but I didn't have any other good options of them playing on stage anyway. I took the band name at the top from a 1972 concert poster.
Always liked the Millington sisters. The vocals remind me of Graeme "Shirley" Strachan from Skyhooks. Thanks for this gem
ReplyDeleteThey are/were.. still doing shows!
ReplyDeletei discovered Fanny on the utubes, and like most everyone else, was blown away by their great rockin vibe! real players!
You mentioned the factors going against them..perhaps should add,though typical of dumb names in the 70s..Fanny..as a band name, probably didn't help.
Thank you..great collection there!
Yeah, the band name didn't help. There's a story that one of the Beatles picked that name for them, but apparently that isn't true. I suspect it came from the erotic novel "Fanny Hill." After all, they did name their third album "Fanny Hill."
DeleteInteresting about the origin of the name. I always thought they should have called themselves Mons Veneris.
DeleteI just redid the link. Musical associate MZ improved the sound quality of the two songs that sound the worst, "Badge" and "Cat Fever." They still sound rough, but not as much as before.
ReplyDeleteI just thought I could add to your excellent post. In the late-middle 60s the NYC "Electric Circus" Venue used to do a residency thing. The club was all about dancing to the bands live & I remember V.U. being the 1st band I remember being there. After came the McCoys & finally Fanny. I went there once & all I remember was cacophony. & I think Fanny.....So somehow perhaps because of their frequent radio play I became a fan. & in finality yes they still play. They've more or less based themselves in Hawaii & they have a wonderful recent album- well worth seeking out & buying "'June & Jean Millington - Ticket to Wonderful"
ReplyDeleteadding a bit more......they've actually reformed as a band not just June & Jean & have a seriously excellent produced new album called "Fanny Walked The Earth" & you allude to an official live album. I have "a boot" I think which is incredibly dynamic called "Fanny Live" an el Pumpkin Archival Production" which is from 2 shows -Cleveland 04-11-72 & Bijou Cafe, Philadelphia 04-21-73. That newest album is totally Beatles. Thanks Again
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteDo you have anything more specific about the dates and the non-Beat Club tracks - where are they from
ReplyDeleteYes, all that info is available in the mp3 tags for every album I post. If you don't know how to see mp3 tags, here's the info for this album:
Delete01 Cat Fever - The Dick Cavett Show (US TV Show), New York City, 9-25-1971
02 Charity Ball - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-23-1971
03 Place in the Country - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-23-1971
04 Hey Bulldog - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-23-1971
05 talk - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-23-1971
06 Thinking of You - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-23-1971
07 talk - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-23-1971
08 Ain't That Peculiar - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-23-1971
09 talk - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-23-1971
10 Blind Alley - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-23-1971
11 talk - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-23-1971
12 Special Care - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-23-1971
13 You're the One - The Old Grey Whistle Test (BBC TV Show), BBC Television Theatre, London, Britain, 12-7-1971
14 Badge - Rock en Stock (French TV Show), 1972
15 Young and Dumb - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-25-1972
16 Summer Song - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-25-1972
17 Knock on My Door - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-25-1972
18 Borrowed Time - Beat Club (German TV Show), Bremen, Germany, 11-25-1972
19 All Mine - The Midnight Special (US TV Show), Burbank, CA, 4-13-1973
20 Last Night I Had a Dream - The Midnight Special (US TV Show), Burbank, CA, 4-13-1973
The Beat Club perfromances are coming out on CD in June 2024.
ReplyDelete