Anyway, this is one of the two projects: a "Covered" collection for one of the greatest songwriters of all time, Neil Young. This one was mostly done by musical friend Fabio from Rio. That includes writing really great liner notes.
---
This is certainly one of the most daunting projects I've worked with Paul yet, and certainly the biggest and most demanding "Covered" collections at the "Albums That Should Exist" blog ever, at least at the time of writing these liner notes.
I assume Neil Young needs no introduction. Everybody (or at least everybody who has not lived in an offline bunker for the last half century) knows that Neil is one of the most important rock artists of the last sixty years. He has been influencing generations of musicians since the 1960s, resulting in literally thousands of covers and tributes, officially and unofficially available on studio albums, tribute records, live performances, and YouTube uploads.
Our aim here was not to include every Neil Young composition (that would easily result in more than 25 volumes), but to present a good representation of his output, including not only the all-time hits but also deep cuts, some officially unreleased songs cherished by long-time fans (the so-called "Rusties"), and at least a few lesser-known but equally strong compositions from more recent years, since Neil has never stopped composing, performing and recording.
We would like this project to become "The Best Neil Young Cover Collection Ever" - not out of personal vanity, but as a tribute to the quality of the songs and artists featured. For that reason, we walked the proverbial extra mile in order to select what we believe are some of the best performances of each song. In some cases, this was quite difficult to determine and remains subject to endless debate, since certain songs have literally hundreds of different versions recorded by dozens of artists. Subjectivity inevitably played a part, since our personal tastes (mine and Paul's) may have resulted in some biased selections. However, we tried whenever possible to focus on performances that are widely recognized as among the best or most representative interpretations of a given song. At the same time, we also looked for unusual readings that might give a different or fresh spin to familiar melodies.
My initial selection comprised about 230 different songs, and I listened to more than a thousand performances (1,072 to be exact) in order to prepare the first short list, which was later shared with Paul. For some songs there were literally dozens of available covers, so our main challenge was deciding which one to include. For others, it was surprisingly difficult to find a strong version. In some cases - particularly with more obscure tunes - we had to resort to unofficial recordings, including some provided by the Rusties community, where both amateur and professional musicians share their interpretations.
Since my initial selection would result in too-long a collection even for die-hard fans standards, Paul made editorial cuts, excluding some songs (which I accepted with stoic dignity), but also requesting the inclusion of some of his personal favorites, which I happily complied. In the end, we settled on a 10-volume collection with about 150 tracks, with very little repetition (only two songs - "Heart of Gold" and "Cortez the Killer" - appear in more than one version, in different volumes).
---
Note that Fabio wrote individual paragraphs about all the songs in this volume. To see that, please look at the Word file added to the download zip file. Thanks again to Fabio for his help putting these albums together.
I also want to add that these albums are ordered by the years the covers were recorded, not the years the songs were first recorded by Neil Young. So if you don't see songs you want included, please wait. There are no less than TEN albums! And for instance, some songs from this time period don't show up until the last one.
This album is an hour and three minutes long.
01 Do I Have to Come Right Out and Say It (Gallery Production)
02 Sugar Mountain (Joni Mitchell)
03 Everybody, I Love You (Happy Day)
04 Round and Round (Bernie Schwartz)
05 Southern Man (Merry Clayton)
06 Birds (Linda Ronstadt)
07 Ohio (Isley Brothers)
08 Only Love Can Break Your Heart (Jackie DeShannon)
09 See the Sky about to Rain (Byrds)
10 New Mama (Stephen Stills)
11 Love Is a Rose (Linda Ronstadt)
12 Mr. Soul (Cher)
13 The Loner (Stephen Stills)
14 Lotta Love (Nicolette Larson)
15 Look Out for My Love (Linda Ronstadt)
16 Like a Hurricane (Roxy Music)
17 Are You Ready for the Country (Jason & the Scorchers)
17 Winterlong (Pixies)
https://pixeldrain.com/u/DW5ar8Yg
alternate:
https://bestfile.io/en/ZnVTE05ucUWZ4Wc/file
The cover photo is from 1966 or 1967. The original was in black and white, but I colorized it with the help of the Kolorize program. I also used the Krea AI program to add detail.

Have a wonderful and safe trip!
ReplyDeleteRoxy Music doing my favorite Neil tune???? Wow!
ReplyDeleteLove your site but that A.I. image of Neil is an abomination.
ReplyDeleteWhat if that's what he looked like?
Deletehttps://www.facebook.com/groups/971699752901504/posts/2538516482886482/
It is no A.I. Image, but an artificially colored image of a real Neil B&W photograph from 1967.
DeleteThis is gonna be great! But I have a question - if volume 1 covers from 1967 all the way to 1989, are volumes 2-10 going to comprise only tracks dating from 1990-2026?
ReplyDeleteIndeed. I was pretty surprised about that myself. It seems there weren't that many Neil Young covers up until about 1990, and then the number of covers exploded. Strange, but that's what it is.
DeleteThat's fascinating in and of itself... I look so forward to this collection - and have a fantastic trip!
DeleteHi Jerry, out of curiosity, I just checked my main folder for this project, and here is the raw data:
Delete1960's recordings - 6 tracks
1970's recordings - 31 tracks
1980's recordings - 37 tracks
1990's recordings - 220 tracks
2000's recordings - 334 tracks
2010's recordings - 270 tracks
2020's recordings - 174 tracks
And this is disconsidering probably around a hundred or so amateur to semi-professional covers from 2010's-2020's that I discarded for some reason (mainly due to poor audio and/or performance).
It is quite clear that there was a boost on Neil Young covers in the 1990's, and it has kept growing since.
SInce we had a total of 74 tracks for the period, we *could* have included more covers from the 60s, 70s and 80s, spreading them through 2 or 3 volumes instead of just one album with 17 tracks, but since our goal was to pick the most representative performance (regardless of by whom or when it was recorded), the final tracklists regarding each decade were naturally closer to the shares I mention above.
DeleteIt makes a sort of sense, in that there's a clear appreciation for his songwriting from the "second generation" of musicians in the '90s & '00s that came up with him as an already-venerated songwriter. It's just surprising to me because many of his songs were already 'recognized' as contemporarily covered (on albums and in concert) by many of his peers, like Ronstadt, Emmylou, Crowell, Stills, and Larson. But the numbers don't lie, so I'm looking for ward to this! (Let me know if you'd like me to send you a recording I just made last month of the Grammy's/AMPAS "Americanafest" at the Troubador in LA, a tribute to Neil by a bunch of hugely talented younger artists they out on the night before the Grammys.)
DeleteThe Guess Who - Flying On The Ground Is Wrong
ReplyDeleteAs I mention at the liner notes, for that project we considered literally more than one thousand different covers. For FOTGIW, we had the Guess Who version as an option, but in the end decided for something completely different, that will appear only at the last album.
DeleteFor a project with such a huge scope, it is nearly impossible foe everyone to agree on what is the "best version" for a given song (and we tried to keep just one cover for each composition, with a couple exceptions to confirm the rule). Some songs had more than 40 different covers for us to choose from. So, it is inevitable that our personal tastes played a part on the choosing.
Having said that, please do comment here what are your favorite versions for a given song, the more the merrier!
Thank You for this. Hope you have a safe trip Paul. There was a 45 single released on record store day back in 2023 it featured Juliana Hatfield doing "Lotta Love" & the flip side was Emma Swift doing "Give Me Strength". Both Neil Young covers.
ReplyDelete